What is School Self Evaluation by Cambridge International ?
The School Self-Evaluation service by Cambridge International is designed to help the school administrators review their school’s performance and identify areas of strength as well as those that could be more effective. It encourages the school to use evidence and data to make informed decisions about areas of school practice that need improvement.
How did “School Self-Evaluation” come to Cedar School ?
Our current CEO, Roque Martin, was very supportive about conducting whole-school evaluation at The Cedar School. He was keen about starting new projects that encouraged self-reflective practices. Hence, when we shared the idea about a “School Self Evaluation with Cambridge International”, he was very excited to implement it at The Cedar School. To initiate the process, we got in touch with the Cambridge Team in Pakistan and started the process. We are thankful to Mr Shahid Ashraf, Miss Hira Sajjad, Miss Tabinda Mazhar and other professionals who facilitated this process.
Planning for Data Collection
We were provided with online surveys by Cambridge International that we used to collect feedback from our school’s key stakeholder groups: parents, students and teachers. These surveys are based around a set of standards for School Self-Evaluation that have been developed specifically for Cambridge International Schools. The standards are grouped into five key areas, or domains, shown below. Each domain contains a set of standards which help to define the features of an effective school.

To ensure the integrity of the surveys, Cambridge issues separate IDs and passwords for these three categories of respondents. We first identified the pool of candidates who would be requested to fill out the survey forms. We selected those participants who had worked with us at least for one academic year as they would be better suited to comment on our programme. Then, once we received the login credentials for the surveys, the team initiated the data collection procedure. Data was collected in 2 weeks and different phases where each stakeholder was dealt with separately.
Surveys of Parents: We started off conducting surveys of parents first where we shared an email with them explaining the purpose of this exercise and the procedure to fill the survey. A reminder email was sent after a week to ensure that majority of the parents submit their responses.
Surveys of Teachers: The team then conducted the surveys of the teachers. The team decided to organise an online meeting with the chosen teachers in which no other school administration was allowed, including the Head of School since we wanted to ensure confidentiality. The team was mindful in answering questions during this process to avoid influencing the responses of the participants.

Surveys of Students: Students surveys were conducted in the end. This was the most challenging task because the strategy used for the other stakeholders could not be applied with the students as they are more susceptible to not following the protocols. In addition, we wanted to follow the same data collection procedures for all grade levels. Since we had to conduct surveys of middle year to higher secondary year students, we decided to involve more manpower and assist students in filling out the forms. An initial training session was held where the team shared the data collection procedures and protocols in detail with the assisting team. Having more people involved in the execution process helped us conduct these surveys simultaneously across all our campuses. The main team also visited the campuses at least twice to assess and to ensure proper implementation of the data collection guidelines.

The Report
Once we had carried out the surveys, Cambridge produced a report based on our results that combined and compared responses from parents, students and teachers. This report helped us in highlighting and celebrating our strengths, identifying challenges and areas for improvement and establishing priorities for future development. Once we received the report, the team held a meeting with the senior management and the Board to share the rationale of this exercise, processes followed and key highlights from the report. This provided an avenue to the decision makers to have a substantial and enriching discussion which was backed by concrete data.

The Results
The report was quite detailed (48 pages long) and the results were divided into two parts — by domain (compared results) and by stakeholders (combined results). Comparing ratings of different stakeholders was beneficial as it allowed us to learn which domain holds higher value for each group. There were certain domains which received higher ratings from more than one group of stakeholders. For instance, students, parents and senior leadership community rated school’s mission and values the highest. This makes the results consistent as all of these stakeholders submitted their responses in different phases and yet they ranked this particular domain the highest. Similarly, combined results were also very crucial for us as the school scored the lowest for dealing with bullying within the school. This provided the senior management with the opportunity to discuss this issue in detail and propose new initiatives to combat bullying at the School.

